Shirley man admits killing pub owner with single punch but denies murder
Billy Allison told a murder trial he was sorry after admitting manslaughter over the death of 44-year-old Matthew O'Gara, who was punched on a Lichfield bar dancefloor
CRIME
Katie Thompson
11/11/20262 min read


A man from Shirley has admitted killing a pub owner with a single punch but denied murdering him, telling a court he was "really sorry" his actions had resulted in someone's death.
Billy Allison, 36, is accused of murdering Matthew O'Gara at the Ricco and Loren bar in Lichfield on May 24.
Stafford Crown Court heard that Allison admitted manslaughter and grievous bodily harm against Mr O'Gara's friend, Adam Cooper, but denied carrying out the attacks with the intention of causing really serious injury or death.
Giving evidence on Tuesday, Allison said: "I'm just really sorry for what I did that night and really sorry my actions caused the end of someone's life."
Asked by his barrister, Gurdeep Gracha KC, whether he had intended to cause really serious injury or kill either man, Allison replied: "Definitely not."
The court heard that Mr O'Gara, 44, was on the dancefloor with his back to Allison when he was struck in the side of the neck.
The pub owner, who ran The Plough on the outskirts of Lichfield, was left unconscious by the blow and died in hospital two days later.
Prosecutor Timothy Hannam KC previously described the incident as an "unprovoked and senseless" attack.
Opening the case last month, he told the jury that Mr O'Gara had been "completely oblivious" to Allison before being punched.
The force of the blow was said to have been loud enough to be heard over the bar's DJ sound system.
Mr Hannam said it was delivered with the "stance and skill of an experienced fighter" and was powerful enough to break several bones and split an artery.
The resulting bleeding caused a haemorrhage at the base of Mr O'Gara's brain, leading to a cardiac arrest.
During his evidence, Allison said he was "not really sure" what his intentions had been when he threw the punch.
"It's a bit of a grey area, I'm not really sure why I did it at the time," he told the court.
The jury also heard about Allison's lifestyle at the time of the incident.
He said he was working six or seven days a week as a groundworker and would drink alcohol a couple of times a month.
He described himself as a "happy drinker" and said alcohol generally made him "chirpy".
Allison also told the court he had taken cocaine perhaps once a month when socialising, saying he did so to "fit in".
The trial heard details of previous offences, including a caution for criminal damage in 2007 and an offence of occasioning actual bodily harm following a fight when he was 18.
He also admitted a racially or religiously aggravated public order offence in 2009, which arose during an arrest for being drunk and disorderly.
Allison said he could not remember exactly what he had said to police but believed it was "something racial".
He told the court he had pleaded guilty to the previous offences because it was the "right thing to do".
Allison is expected to continue giving evidence on Wednesday morning.
The trial continues.

What's On Solihull
Independent street-level news, council updates, and community reporting across Solihull Borough.
Sitemap
Home
News
What's On
Community
About
Contact
© 2026 What's On Solihull-Published by Infinity Media. Verified West Midlands news and community reporting.


